a guest said my show felt like an ai

in a debrief, a guest told me my interview felt like talking to an ai screening bot. he was right about why, and it taught me something about format and feeling.

share x linkedin facebook

a microphone on a stand facing a small boxy robot across a warm meadow, under a wide pale sky with a few clouds

on thursday i did a short debrief call with a guest from the week before. i always ask how the episode felt from their side. most people say it was great. he told me the truth.

he said the interview started to feel like he was talking to an ai. like one of those automated job screening interviews where an avatar reads you a question, waits, then reads the next one.

that stung a bit. it was also the most useful feedback i've had on the show in months.

he walked me through why. between questions there were small visual jumps. my headset was on, then off. my hands were in a different spot. the question banner on screen came in with a little glitch. to him it looked like the video had cut, like something had restarted on the next prompt. he said it distracted him for the first few questions and he had trouble finding his words.

the bigger point was about structure. each question felt like a sealed box. i'd ask, he'd answer, i'd move to the next one on the list. no follow-up on what he'd just said. no tell me more.

i owed him, and myself, an honest answer about why the show works that way. the tight format is great for clips. every answer stands on its own, so it can become a short without any setup. organic follow-ups are harder to clip because they depend on what came before. i built the format for distribution.

and he's right that the cost is the feeling. a conversation where nobody follows up isn't a conversation. it's a questionnaire with a camera.

here's what i'm taking from it.

first, the questions should be a map, not a script. i send guests a bank of questions before we tape, and i'm going to hold the list with a lighter grip. when something interesting comes up, i'll chase it.

second, the small production details aren't small. a glitchy animation or a headset going on and off changes how the guest feels, and how the guest feels changes what they say. that's the real product.

third, i joked with him that an ai avatar could do a hundred of these interviews a day. he laughed. but the joke has a point inside it. if my interviews feel like an ai could do them, then an ai will do them, and nobody will care whether it was me.

the lesson goes beyond podcasts. any process you've optimized for efficiency can start to feel mechanical to the person on the other end, whether it's a sales call or a support queue. the metrics look great and the customer feels like a ticket number.

long term, as more of the world gets automated, the human feel of a conversation becomes the premium. people will pay for the follow-up question.

if you want to watch the show and judge for yourself, it's all on the show page.

so when was the last time you asked a customer how your process felt... and wanted the honest answer?

share x linkedin facebook
the newsletter

the machine economy brief

one email when it matters: bitcoin, ai, robotics, and what founders should do about it. unsubscribe anytime.

no spam, no list-selling. your email goes to sunny, nowhere else.

this is the thesis i'm building on.

i write the machine economy brief: bitcoin x ai x robotics, where it's all going, once a week.

join the machine economy brief →