← sunnyray.com
The Sunny Ray Show · Episode Page

I Bought Back the Company I Started · Stacy Spikes, MoviePass

Stacy Spikes · Founder, MoviePass (also founder of the Urban World film festival) · 40:14
watch on youtube ↗

What we talked about.

Sunny Ray talks with Stacy Spikes, founder of MoviePass, about building the first theatrical subscription service and then buying it back. Spikes traces the idea from his Urban World film festival and the 2011 thinking behind an all you can go model, and he recalls five years of rejection from theaters, studios and producers. He explains why subscriptions beat re-acquiring customers every weekend, and he describes watching a private equity owner run the company into bankruptcy after a lock-up and stock deal. He then explains how he bought MoviePass back in 2022 for $140,000, using fan enthusiasm and the 1918 pandemic recovery as signals. The conversation covers the credit system that aligns member behavior with theater economics, the rebuilt trust helped by an HBO documentary, and how AI agents can book seats with a MoviePass card. Spikes also previews MOGOL, a daily fantasy game for Hollywood, outlines the busy holiday and awards season ahead, and closes with advice for founders who have lost control of their companies.

Stacy Spikes explains how he bought back MoviePass for $140,000 after bankruptcy and why persistence beat five years of no.

The questions, and the answers.

What does MoviePass do, and what problem are you solving?

MoviePass launched in 2012 and was basically Netflix for movie theaters. I knew plenty of people go to the movies often, and I wanted to give them value by getting wholesale pricing on tickets when they go more. We offered the first theatrical subscription service, and it works as a go anywhere service at any theater.

How many people told you nobody would pay monthly to go to the movies?

Everybody, for five years. All the theaters said no, all the studios said no, and a producer said no. They were polite and basically escorted me to the door. Their mindset was sight and sound, plus food and beverage, so a new business model was not on their radar. The smartphone eventually opened up the whole universe.

What is the first lesson about subscriptions that still holds today?

Subscriptions are beautiful because you don't have to re-acquire the customer. In the movie industry, every Friday night we have to win people over all over again, and it can cost about as much to convince them to come as the ticket costs. With a subscription, people pre-commit, so you capture revenue and spend less on advertising.

What was it like to watch the company you started go in a direction you wouldn't have taken?

It was hostile and rogue, and it went bad fast. After spending 10 to 12 years building something, watching people tear it down in a few months was hardcore. The model didn't fail. It was poor business, with pricing that lacked the right economics. We had a 12 month lock-up in a stock deal, and the stock went to zero in under nine months.

What made you decide to buy MoviePass back, and what made you sure?

Fans were posting videos online saying they wanted their MoviePass back and missed being in a room with other people. I also looked at the 1918 pandemic, after which most of today's studios were born in 1920. The data said people would return. When it went up for sale in summer 2022, I got the money together and bought it back for $140,000 out of bankruptcy.

What did you change first when it was yours again?

We added credits. Some theaters were paying full price and others were wholesale, and members couldn't tell the difference. Now you get a monthly allotment of credits and spend more on opening night and fewer on off-peak showings, like Monday through Thursday or before 4 p.m. That aligns members with our economics, and our average margin is 30% now.

How did you rebuild trust with members and theaters after the headlines?

We did a lot of press and told the story of what happened. Then the HBO documentary came out and was nominated for an Emmy, and it did the heavy lifting. People in Reddit chat rooms defended us, saying we were the original founders and not the ones who blew it up. It felt like being back under the original management.

What would you tell a founder who has lost control of their company and wants it back?

Don't give up. Keep your eye on the ball. People who built some of the most valuable companies in the world have walked through this, so you are in good company. If it happens, don't let it go to your head, and understand that you have a knowledge base.

MoviePassSubscription BusinessFounder ComebackMovie TheatersUrban World Film FestivalAI and MoviegoingMOGOL Fantasy Hollywood

Stacy Spikes

Founder, MoviePass (also founder of the Urban World film festival)

Building something daring? Sunny talks to founders like this every day. Fifteen minutes to see if your story belongs on the stage.

Claim your pre-interview
All episodes →
The engine

The machine behind every conversation on this page.

See the three sizes
Your link

Send a founder here and we will know it was you.

The Machine Economy Brief

One email a week. The best ideas from the show, read through bitcoin, AI and robots, and what founders should do about them.

Built with help from AI. We use AI tools to research, draft, and assemble pages like this one. A human reviews everything, but if something looks off, tell us and we will fix it fast.