if it arrives as a pdf, it's a commodity

anything delivered through a screen is heading toward free. the offers that hold their price are the ones that happen in a room with people in it.

share x linkedin facebook

a flat warm meadow stretches across the page, with a small boxy robot on the left and a single full tree on the right under a pale sun

this afternoon, in a debrief with a guest who works with authors and experts, the conversation turned into one of the most useful segments we've recorded in a while. it was about what ai does to the price of everything delivered through a screen.

the claim on the table was simple. if your deliverable arrives as a pdf, a video file, a line of code or a design link, it's heading toward commodity pricing. ai can produce a version of it for free in minutes.

that doesn't mean the ai version is as good. it often isn't. the point we kept landing on is that most clients don't need the masterpiece. for something like nine out of ten of them, an output that's eighty percent as good and almost free beats an expensive one that's perfect. the price to performance trade has moved for good.

that's an uncomfortable thought if you sell copy or code, and i sell some of those things too. so we asked the obvious next question. what can't be cloned?

the answer we kept coming back to was presence, an experience that happens in a room with real people at a real time. think of a dinner where the right ten people meet each other. an ai can write the agenda, but it can't be the room.

one example that came up was a small group event in bali, around twenty-five people, with an older mentor who'd built several fortunes presenting live. it was described as more transformational than any digital product ever sold by the people who ran it. that rings true to me. i've bought plenty of courses i never finished. i remember every room i've been in that changed how i think.

the economics follow. in-person programs were said to command three to five times the price of a comparable online offer. and the barrier to building one isn't money. it's comfort. it's much easier to sell a pdf from your desk than to stand in front of twenty-five people who paid to be there.

i'd add one thing from my own world. i spend most of my days in conversations, and the show works because it's live. the guest and i are figuring something out together in real time. the clips are a byproduct of that. if i tried to replace the conversation with a generated script, the whole thing would lose its value overnight.

this applies to founders who don't sell services too. look at what your customer experiences as human, like the onboarding call or the dinner where they first met you. those are the parts of your business that resist commoditization. protect them and invest in them while everyone else automates.

long term, i think the price of things made on a screen keeps falling toward zero, and the price of being in the room keeps rising. both trends are good news if you know which side your business is on.

more on where i think ai creates value and where it doesn't is in the ai book.

so take inventory... how much of what you sell could arrive as a pdf?

share x linkedin facebook
the newsletter

the machine economy brief

one email when it matters: bitcoin, ai, robotics, and what founders should do about it. unsubscribe anytime.

no spam, no list-selling. your email goes to sunny, nowhere else.

this is the thesis i'm building on.

i write the machine economy brief: bitcoin x ai x robotics, where it's all going, once a week.

join the machine economy brief →